Carrier Shipping vs. Tow Dolly

Amerifreight image

You may be considering renting a tow dolly from U-Haul because it is one of the most cost-effective ways to transport your vehicle, but you should weigh all of your options before making a final decision.  The most difficult decision you'll have to make is whether to rent a tow dolly or a car carrier. Lucky for you, that's exactly what this post is all about.

What are the Differences?

How They Work

A car dolly, also known as a tow dolly, is a two-wheel trailer that lifts only your vehicles front wheels. When you use a tow dolly to tow your vehicle, the rear wheels stay on the ground. A car carrier is a trailer that lifts your vehicle completely off the ground.


Most front-wheel-drive vehicles, as well as a few all-wheel-drive, rear-wheel-drive, and four-wheel-drive vehicles, can use a dolly. At the same time, due to weight constraints, it's not the best option for towing heavier cars.

A car trailer, on the other hand, can move even larger vehicles such as trucks and customized automobiles. To handle your vehicle's weight, the carrier can simply make some alterations. If it's a bigger automobile, for example, they'll reduce the number of vehicles the trailer transports for that trip so it doesn't surpass the maximum weight restriction.

Ease of Use

Connecting your vehicle to a dolly might be tricky, especially if you've never done it before. You must ensure that the drive wheels are exceptionally secure to avoid any potential for mishaps. This is significant since you can't use the emergency brake to keep a car in place when towing it with a tow dolly.

When towing a rear-wheel drive vehicle, the configuration becomes even more difficult. Due to front clearance concerns, you may even need to remove the drive shafts.

Vehicle towing using a car trailer, on the other hand, involves very little work on your part. The carrier will load and unload the vehicle for you, making the process simple for you.


When it comes to price, renting a dolly is usually the most cost-effective solution. A tow dolly rental from U-Haul, for example, costs roughly $98. Auto transport pricing will vary widely depending on the distance you need to ship your vehicle. To see estimated pricing you should use a rate calculator to compare pricing against using a dolly. 

If you don't have a vehicle to tow the dolly with, you may incur additional rental, installation, and fuel costs. Furthermore, most moving firms will only rent dollies if you also rent a truck from them, thus the cost of hiring a dolly will be added to your overall price.

There is also the reality that towing another vehicle behind a truck reduces your gas mileage dramatically. This will result in higher gasoline costs because you'll require more gas to cover the same distance than normal.


Trailer sway, or the fishtailing movement that happens when driving at a fast speed, is one of the most serious automobile dolly towing concerns. It's one of the most common causes of towing accidents, and it's especially dangerous when towing your car in bad weather because the roads become slick, making it even more difficult to maintain control of the vehicle.

In this regard, a carrier is far safer than dollies because the entire vehicle is loaded onto the trailer. There is less risk because the driver only has to concentrate on controlling the vehicle they are driving.


During vehicle towing, rental providers recommend driving at a slower-than-average speed. As previously stated, this is primarily to promote safety and prevent trailer swaying. Maintaining a slower driving speed lengthens your journey greatly and can increase gas costs. 

Car shipment carriers are subject to speed regulations as well, but because there is no risk of trailer sway, they can go a little faster than dollies-equipped vehicles.


Another issue with vehicle towing is the ability to maneuver with the dolly . So, you're probably wondering if you can back up with a tow dolly. Although possible, unskilled drivers may find it difficult. If you haven't done it before, backing up to place the towed vehicle in the proper location may be difficult.

Car haulers, on the other hand, do not have the same difficulties. The driver just has to control the vehicle they're driving because the full vehicle has been loaded onto the carrier. This makes backing up and maneuvering considerably easier.

So which option is right for you? 

Ultimately, the decision is entirely dependent on your requirements. A  dolly should only be used for short-distance towing and for vehicles that do not exceed the weight limit. For cross-country vehicle travel and cars that are heavier than what a tow dolly can carry, use a car carrier.

Going with the cheapest choice isn't always the best option because you'll be sacrificing a lot in the process, including safety and vehicle condition. 

To sum it all up, before making a decision you should thoroughly examine your requirements and choose the option that will provide you with the most convenience and safety. 


Related Posts

5 Reasons To Have Your Car Shipped

When it comes time to make the decision to have your car shipped or drive it yourself, keep in mind the benefits of shipping your car. There are many reasons you may need to have your car shipped across country. Maybe you have a new job opportunity, starting college, or relocating for family. Whatever the reason, AmeriFreight can handle all of the ins and outs for you. If you’re leaning towards driving yourself we have 5 reasons to ship with us instead.

Honesty & Transparency

The car shipping business can have a bad reputation at times. There are many horror stories from customer who’ve dealt with dishonest brokers. Unfortunately, there are brokers that make frivolous promises that cannot be kept. Here are some signs to be aware of.

Transporting Cars During Covid-19

We are facing dangerous & unprecedented times as a country due to the Covid-19 Pandemic. Many businesses and industries are implementing extra safety measures to combat this virus. AmeriFreight is following the guidelines given by the CDC to promote safety. We are asking that our customers also follow these guidelines. We’ve compiled a small list of do’s and don’ts to follow if you are having your vehicle transported.

Shipping Your Vehicle With Amerifreight

The shipping of vehicles is widely practiced by the American public, yet there are still many misconceptions about this industry. However, there are many “good-to-knows” that can make your experience a far more pleasant one.

Open versus Enclosed Carriers.

Everyone has different preferences when it comes to shipping their personal vehicles. You may be shipping a luxury, exotic, or classic car that would benefit from an enclosed auto transport for extra protection. Maybe you are shipping a fixer upper that needs to be repaired so you’re not too concerned. Whatever the case may be, there are different types of carriers that can fit your need!

Winterizing Your Vehicle

Winter and all of the conditions that come with it can be tough on you vehicle. Experts recommend prepping your car for winter conditions so it can safely make it to spring. The following is a list of steps to take to make sure your car is ready for the season.

Trailers Used in Vehicle Transportation

You've probably never given much attention to the many trailer and truck alternatives available for moving automobiles even if you're planning to ship. Auto transportation is one of those services that is mostly unnoticed until it is required. W e're here to assist you and will select the best vehicle shipping trailer for your needs and would like to clarify a few differences in trailer style.  We find the different vehicle shipping options fascinating, so we thought it would be fun to put together a post that explains the differences between the types of trucks and trailers transporters use in the shipping industry. 

Shipping Across State Lines

Information on shipping your vehicle across state lines and why it may be a better option than driving.

AmeriFreight Short Answer Bonanza!

We look at all the scattered short answers from our website

Online Vehicle Purchase and Delivery

Learn about buying your car online and having it shipped to you

Different Methods of Vehicle Shipment

Different Methods of Vehicle Shipment

Hiring a Driver vs. Shipping Your Car

When you need to transport a vehicle across the country, your initial instinct might be to drive it yourself. And if driving it yourself isn't an option, you're likely to consider having someone else drive it for you. Even while each means of transportation has its own set of advantages and disadvantages, there are strong reasons to pick auto transport over a personal driving service.

Open Auto Transport: The most common way to ship

When it comes to car shipment, open auto transport is a fully-insured mode of transportation that is quite inexpensive and gives very good protection against any accidents that may occur to your vehicle during the transfer.

The main authority regulating the transport industry

The main authority regulates the transport industry through different entities or agencies, which are focused on main processes related to transportation. Each of them has their own rules and regulations, and work effectively to control the traveling process across the country.

Fuel Efficient Cars

Fuel efficient or electric cars are both excellent alternatives for driving efficiency, costs and environmental impacts. The following list shows the top car options for each type, according to main characteristics such as mpg or battery range.

Car Moving Tips

Keep in mind the following tips for shipping your vehicle. Selecting a trustable company with great service, price, as well as knowing what to expect and do before transporting your car, are key factors that you need to know in order to pick up your car at your desired destination.

Shipping a Forklift

Shipping a forklift involves several unique factors that differ from a typical car transport experience. Take a look at them here.

Making the Move to Hawaii

Moving to Hawaii can be very exciting! Hawaii has a culture all its own, so there is much to learn. A beautiful locale, Hawaii offers so much for both the visitor and the long-term resident.

FMCSA Surety Bonds - What Does this Mean?

Surety Bonds are crucial if you want the FMCSA to issue your license. Only use a fully licensed and bonded broker to move your vehicle. Anyone without such credentials is probably not reputable.

Car Preventive Maintenance: What You Need to Know

There are certain steps you must follow in order to drive your car safely. Don’t know them yet? Check out some important tips for keeping your Vehicle’s Preventive Maintenance up to date!

FMCSA Launches Training Provider Registry

Future commercial drivers will be glad about the new Training Provider Registry by the FMCSA. A fully online registration process and data-base, will allow them to request their CDL in a much easier way, ensuring their knowledge on safety rules and processes when driving. Read the full article and check what the entire TPR consists of.

Distracted Driving: A Lot More Dangerous Than You Think

Distracted driving comes in many different forms. From texting your friend to singing your favorite song, you’re putting yourself in danger if you don’t know how to manage it or the ways to avoid it. Check the following tips and info about it, and drive safely wherever you go!

Dangers of driving tired or sleepy

Did you know that driving tired or sleepy is one of the main causes of accidents throughout the United States? Thousands of car accidents occur each year due to this dangerous effect. Try having a sleeping routine, avoid using electronic devices and taking naps if necessary before driving. We’ll show you how to do it the easiest way.

Top 10 Sites to Buy and Sell Used Cars

Selling or buying a car, whether it is used or new, vintage or a luxury, is quite easy with the 10 top sites shown here. Each of them contain different methods and types of selling and buying, but all of them are trustable, transparent, qualified and easy to use. Check them out!

The Best Websites to Sell Your Car

Planning to buy a new car but want to get rid of your old one? Check out the best and trustable websites to sell your car in a simple, quick way!

The Ultimate List of Most Popular U.S Cities to Move to in 2022

The best cities to live in this 2022 are listed here! Job opportunities, outdoor activities, transportation options, and students' needs were based on this research to define the most popular ones. Check them out!

Tips on Getting the Best Mileage on Your Vehicle

Having a good car gas mileage is crucial when it comes to maintaining a vehicle in good conditions. Check some tips on how to do it and keep your vehicle in perfect condition.

The difference between a Broker and a Carrier

Wondering if a broker and a carrier are both the same? Well, get rid of this doubt and see their main functions during vehicle transportation!

Car Delivery from Dealership

Delivering your car from a car dealership is pretty simple. Follow the next steps so that your new vehicle gets home delivered in the best possible, successful way!

15 Essential Questions to Ask the Best Car Shipping Companies

Looking for the right company to ship your car? Read here to find the most essential questions to ask the best car shipping companies before you decide.

How Do Car Vending Machines Work?

Car vending machines are the new way of buying and selling cars. Still haven't joined the revolution? Check how it works!

Everything You Need to Know About Car Auctions

Wondering how auto auctions work? Well, keep reading and find out why this is the preferred car buying method for thousands of car enthusiasts across the country and the globe!

The Importance of a Bill of Lading

Get a clear and quick understanding of what the Bill of Lading is, and why it is important for your next vehicle auto transport.

Types of Trailers for Car Shipping

Did you know there are different types of car hauler trailers that can come open or enclosed? Check them out and select your favorite for your next auto transport experience!

Finding Your Next Car with AutoTempest

AutoTempest, the best way to find your next car in 4 easy steps. And the best part of it all: it’s completely free and online!

Auto Transport Terms You Should Know

Understanding vehicle transport terms for your next shipment is crucial! Check some of the most popular ones here.

Shipping Vintage Motorcycles

Is vintage motorcycle shipping possible? Of course, it is. Most bike riders prefer this system because it's safe and takes less time rather than driving to new locations. Check some of the best tips to ship your motorcycle across the nation!

What To Do if Your Car Gets Damaged During Transport

Although most professional auto transport companies have rigorous shipping processes, the risk of getting a vehicle damaged in transit is still there. Therefore, there are key aspects you should follow, such as buying insurance coverage, in order to make your auto transport service a great experience.